Skip to content

Overcrowded Schools and Student Learning

May 9, 2010

At this time of the year, schools in my district begin planning the teaching assignments for the following year.  As we worked on the teacher matrix we took into account the complexities around which  year-round schools must maneuver:  the number of English Learners on each track,  equity and access to all programs, a balance of teacher experience across tracks, etc.  “I’m glad it’s the last time we have to deal with this,” commented one department chair.  Then it hit me; as of 2012, there would be no more year-round schools left in Los Angeles, this being the legacy of Governor Roy Romer and his school construction program.

For as long as I can remember, I have attended or worked in year-round schools.  The memory of carrying boxes for my teacher, from one room to the next, as a 4th grader, is indelibly recorded in my mind.  The majority of my 15 years of teaching has involved a careful choreography of rooms between two other teachers and myself, as to who gets which cabinet to store their materials, which visual aids should be left on the wall, and how we prefer our chairs to be arranged.  All of this, of course, has an impact on student learning.

Setting up a classroom is something that takes weeks to do.  Most teachers in a year-round school rarely have the luxury of time in setting up their rooms.  In Los Angeles, teachers get exactly half a day, because students from the outgoing track are dismissed at 12:30 pm.  The teachers are given access to their rooms shortly thereafter.  Students arrive the next morning.  Ideally, a classroom would be carefully designed to inspire students about the particular subject they will study in that classroom that year; visuals, posters, artifacts, quotes, even college diplomas and teaching credentials would be carefully displayed in different parts of the room.  Instructions for rules, routines and procedures would also be prominent.  Student models of a particular project also have a place in the room.

For year-round teachers in overcrowded schools, this is something toward which we aspire.  The reality is that setting up a room like this ends up happening in concert with the start of the semester.  We make it happen.

Now, as we embark on our final year as an overcrowded school, a new challenge looms.  Depending on how many students are siphoned away by the new middle school opening in 2012, designed to relieve our overcrowding, we may have to employ what are called “roving teachers.”  Each school has a finite number of rooms for teachers.  But if more students enroll than there are rooms for teachers, then the additional teachers hired will not be assigned a room of their own.  Instead, they will travel from room to room, period by period, using vacant rooms which are available because it is that teacher’s conference period.

If sharing rooms on a year-round schedule poses a challenge, it is nothing compared to being a roving teacher.  In this scenario, teachers use a cart to transport reference material, books, office supplies, lesson plans, from one room to the next.  In each room, a bulletin board is supposed to be made available for them, as well as a section of a cabinet.  Teachers do the best they can under these circumstances, but it is the least productive for learning.  “It is an inconvenience for adults, but not for children,” as one administrator put it.  This is questionable.

As leaders debate what constitutes a good school, what defines excellence in academics, we hear more and more voices referring to teachers as expendable and interchangeable workers who should be able to achieve phenomenal results regardless of work conditions and socioeconomic dynamics.  As a teacher in the classroom, I believe that individual schools are different and complex, that there are vast differences in circumstances that should make the education reform debate highly nuanced and organic.  Something as seemingly insignificant as having your own classroom, in which you can maintain a filing cabinet of resources, a closet full of supplies for students, a student library of books you have read and can recommend to kids makes a difference in student learning.  It counts; it matters. Students immediately get a feel for you as a teacher by what they see in the classroom.  Your room can be a magical tool that compels students to wonder and imagine about new learning, a reference tool that provides students with access to materials they don’t have at home, or even just a safe place where they know no one will hurt them.  Or, it can be a place that stifle creativity at best, turn students off from learning at worst.

Governor Romer led the Los Angeles Unified School district for six years.  But his foresight in building schools for children will  be remembered and appreciated.  As we begin our final year in an overcrowded school, teachers are already excitedly discussing ideas for their classroom design 15 months from now.  I wonder if we can paint the walls?

4 Comments leave one →
  1. May 17, 2010 4:26 pm

    Great post, Martha! I once taught behind the stage in a cafetorium, desks crammed into a space bounded by the backdrop of the last play, the props cage and doors to the rest rooms which were supposed to double as dressing rooms on play night–and meant that kids who were visiting the restroom during the day often unbolted the back door to see who was backstage. Restroom noises were also a feature of our day–it’s hard to concentrate on linear functions with a constant back channel of flushing all day long. It was “inconvenient” for everyone.

    • David B. Cohen permalink*
      May 17, 2010 5:17 pm

      Nancy, I thought for sure that “linear functions” was setting up a punchline regarding other functions…

  2. Ann Lackland permalink
    November 21, 2010 9:17 am

    I was so relieved/validated to see your comments and concerns about roving teachers. I have 4 different rooms, 2 (decorated!) carts and stairs (no elevator) to content with.

    I teach Spanish which means lots of props, food prep at times,craft materials and lots of time needed just to get things to where they are. I even teach Spanish in a Japanese/History room and some rooms have doc cams some don’t.

    I’m currently working on my ‘SMART’ professional goal for the year and am trying to highlight this issue for our admin, yet also want to obviously counter the effects of traveling to be en even more effective teacher.

    Any ideas, feedback, stories, reasearch, data welcome!

    • November 21, 2010 10:26 pm

      You have my heartfelt sympathy at this challenging situation. On the one hand, it is good exercise and it forces you to be organized. On the other, you are not always at your best when you don’t have a room to call your own. There is nothing like it.

      That said, I would be moving more towards online storage of materials. This way, the main item I would need would be my laptop. As long as each room had a projector, you would be set up. You can do audio files, videos, and any other document you might need to project.

      Instead of carrying the textbook around, I would copy the pages and make only a class set that students can share. When times are hard, everyone has to work together.

      If your school has enough funding, I would buy multiple copies of the same posters and visuals. These could be stored in each room. There is no point in you burning yourself out because then your students would be left without a teacher. Survival is key.

      I wish you the best of luck during the rest of the year. Hang in there!

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s

%d bloggers like this: