Skip to content

ACT Publications

Promoting Quality Teaching: New Approaches to Compensation and Career Pathways

This report, produced by a team of teacher leaders from a variety of schools and regions in California, follows up on our teacher evaluation report of 2010 (see below).

While education reform leaders rightly point to compensation as an important lever in hiring and retention, common notions of performance-pay reflect a misunderstanding of the teaching profession.  They also fail, consistently, when implemented as simplistic rewards for raising student test scores.  Instead of looking at pay in isolation, policy makers should look at compensation in connection to the work that teachers do, paying higher salaries to effective teachers who take on additional roles and responsibilities.  In this report, we suggest that California should explore the creation of a higher-tier teacher certification that identifies leaders in the profession, and rewards them not simply with money, but with increased compensation commensurate with new leadership roles beyond classroom.

Read the executive summary [PDF – 232k]

Read the full report [PDF – 872k] 


A Quality Teacher in Every Classroom:

An Evaluation System that Works for California


.Our first report, on the topic of teacher evaluation, came out in 2010. We chose to begin here because we believe that without a common understanding of what constitutes teaching quality and how teachers should be evaluated, any further conversation about improving teaching will be inconsequential. The recommendations in this report are drawn from research, analysis of existing policies, input from academic experts, and our own experiences as promoters of quality teaching. This report offers our recommendations on making teacher evaluation a more useful tool to advance the quality of teaching across California.

You can read more here about how this report was put together.

Read the report press release: ACT – Quality Teacher Press Release

Read the executive summary (PDF, 180 KB):  ACT- A Quality Teacher… Executive Summary

Read the full report (PDF, 1.1 MB): ACT- A Quality Teacher in Every Classroom

We welcome your questions and comments.

36 Comments leave one →
  1. May 31, 2010 6:44 am

    I believe there are two ways to make a significant impact on improving schools. 1. Hiring great teachers that you would want the building to be more like. After hiring them you must support them, usher them in with an understanding that you want the school to be more like them not vice versa. 2. Evaluating the teachers you currently have. The best way to impact students on a daily basis is by having effective classroom instruction (or facilitation).

  2. January 2, 2011 6:52 pm

    I just finished reading the report A Quality Teaching in Every Classroom. It is refreshing to read a report that both points out the problems with our current evaluation system in detail and provides for possible solutions. I recently had a conversation with a union rep about utilizing peer review and the response did not support this method. The reasoning was that teachers were not competent enough as they became involved in a power struggle with the teacher being evaluated. Although not provided with details, I could infer from the situation that there was probably not a clear understanding of roles. The research from A Quality Teaching in Every Classroom provides a framework for models that work. My hope is that the approaches mentioned in the report will be considered by policymakers, educators and all stakeholders as the debate continues.

  3. tariqhayat permalink
    March 31, 2011 7:47 am

    Thanks for Sharing. They are really helpful


  1. This Is The Best Resource I’ve Seen On Teacher Evaluation | Larry Ferlazzo's Websites of the Day...
  2. ACT Report: Improve Teacher Evaluation « InterACT
  3. Education Overload « InterACT
  4. The Best Resources For Learning About Effective Student & Teacher Assessments | Larry Ferlazzo's Websites of the Day...
  5. Evaluating Teachers with VAM: Variable Ambiguous Mistake « InterACT
  6. Evaluating Teachers with VAM: Variable Ambiguous Mistake « InterACT « Parents 4 democratic Schools
  7. Evaluating Teachers with VAM: Variable Ambiguous Mistake | Ecology of Education
  8. “The Danger of a Single Story” (Part Two) « InterACT
  9. Teacher, Improve Thyself… | Reflections on Teaching
  10. Evaluation: A personal perspective | Reflections on Teaching
  11. Why I’m Afraid The Gates Foundation Might Be Minimizing Great Tools For Helping Teachers Improve Their Craft | Larry Ferlazzo's Websites of the Day...
  12. 100th Blog Post at InterACT « InterACT
  13. Hoover Experts Strike Out « InterACT
  14. 2010: InterACT in Review « InterACT
  15. Who Evaluates Teachers, and Why? « InterACT
  16. Who Evaluates Teachers, and Why? | Ecology of Education
  17. Union Proud « InterACT
  18. ASCD Day 2 – Focus on Evaluation « InterACT
  19. Appeal to Education Writers: Evaluate Opinions « InterACT
  20. VAM Nauseum: Bleeding the Patient « InterACT
  21. Fox Business and Terry Moe Distort Education Issues to Slam Unions « InterACT
  22. NBPTS on Teacher Evaluation: Getting it Right « InterACT
  23. Which Path to Excellence in Education? « InterACT
  24. Turning the Tables: VAM on Trial « InterACT
  25. Wrapping Up 2011: Best Guest Posts on InterACT « InterACT
  26. Teaching Quality and California’s Future « InterACT
  27. Teaching Quality Summit Review « InterACT
  28. Registration Open for March 26th Meeting | San Mateo County School Board Association Registration Open for March 26th Meeting | San Mateo County
  29. The Beatings Will Continue Until Morale Improves « InterACT
  30. Advocate for the Right Tools in Teacher Evaluation « InterACT
  31. Educator Excellence Task Force Calls for “Greatness by Design” « InterACT
  32. Teaching Career Pathways: Leading Professional Development « InterACT
  33. Teaching Career Pathways: Leading Professional Development « InterACT

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s

%d bloggers like this: